Health data has been vital for national and local policy and decision makers during the pandemic and is helping us to understand the long-term impact on people’s health.  

New data collections have helped us understand the changing pattern of infections, which reached their highest ever level in the first week of April this year, when 1 in 13 people in England had COVID-19. Data told us about the consequences of the pandemic – that so far over 175,000 people in the UK have died from COVID-19 and that in May 2022, 1 in 36 of us were reporting long-COVID symptoms. And data told us about progress with vaccinations – with more than 9 in 10 of those eligible for a vaccination now having had at least one. Data was extensively used in the No. 10 pandemic briefings to reassure the public that the government’s response was being informed by the latest trends.  

There have also been novel uses of existing data to answer pressing questions. At the Health Foundation we’ve worked with a major provider of digital primary care systems to look at how GP practices used technology to engage with patients online during the pandemic. And through our Networked Data Lab we found ways of looking at how the health care use of clinically extremely vulnerable patients who were asked to shield was affected.  

The availability of large COVID-related datasets has also stimulated people from outside the health field to analyse data, produce insights and visualise the data in innovative ways. Overall, the pandemic has shown how data, when used well, can help us understand and address the challenges faced in health and social care, and improve services. This is an opportunity the Government is keen to exploit with its ambitiously titled draft data strategy, published last summer, Data Saves Lives, Reshaping Health and Social Care with Data. The Health Foundation, which has long championed the power of data and has invested heavily in supporting data and analytics, welcomes this new interest, and the priority being given to creating and using new data assets.  

But data can also be misused and cause harm. Health data has been used disingenuously to promote misleading narratives about NHS performance (such as waiting times for elective care) when in reality the issues are much more complex.  

And neither is more data a panacea to the challenges health and care faces. If it were, the UK, with its world class data assets, would have had a better pandemic performance relative to other countries. In addition to more data, several other things are needed. 

First, rather than starting with the data we have, we need to start with an understanding of the things that matter to people. This may require the collection of new data on those things.  

Although technology and automated systems are generating thousands of gigabytes of new data, there are still major gaps in what we know. Take mental health for example. Over the last nine months, through our Networked Data Lab, we have been working with colleagues in five areas across the UK to use local data and analysis to understand and improve the performance of mental health services for children and young people. But what became clear was that, despite making the most of linked data assets available within areas, key data needed for good policymaking or services is lacking. For example, no data were available on services accessed in schools or the community, or services funded by local government or the voluntary sector. There is also a lack of data on use of privately funded mental health services, which may be growing as NHS services have struggled.  

Second, related to this, there needs to be a greater awareness of who is missing from the data that’s collected and the biases this may introduce. For example, the adult social care survey is used to assess how effectively local authority funded services help service users to live safely and independently in their own homes. But because it is only a survey of users, it excludes the increasing number of people who don’t receive services because their needs aren’t deemed to be high enough. As a result, it tells us nothing about unmet need.  

Gaps in data can have more insidious effects too. If data driven tools, powered by algorithms and artificial intelligence, are developed using only data from people in certain population groups, they may not help those from outside these groups – potentially increasing inequality

Third, once we’ve got the data, we need to analyse it properly to avoid drawing false conclusions. There are a variety of mistakes that can be made. Confusing correlation with causation is a common one. Another is not comparing like-with-like. For example, data may show that patients treated by one service have worse outcomes than those treated by another; but this may be solely because the first service has been treating sicker patients. The Improvement Analytics Unit has been set up to help with precisely these sorts of issues, ensuring that the effect of service changes are robustly evaluated. My colleague Arne talks more about this in his interview.  

And fourth, if analysis of data is to save lives and improve health it needs to influence decision makers and the people they listen to or take advice from.  

Some of this is in the hands of data analysts. How they communicate their work is important. At the Health Foundation we spend a lot of time curating data and analysis about key issues, for example through our What drives health inequalities? evidence hub, which brings together data, insights and analysis exploring how the circumstances in which we live shape our health.  

But, perhaps more importantly, there needs to be a culture of evidence-informed policymaking and a demand for good data-driven analysis, including that which challenges existing beliefs.  

We all have roles to play here. Decision makers and advisers need to stay curious and open to challenge. And as citizens we must all do our bit to hold decision makers to account and demand openness about the data and evidence on which decisions are based. 

 

Charles Tallack (@CharlesTTHF) is Interim Director of Data Analytics at the Health Foundation.

This content originally featured in our email newsletter, which explores perspectives and expert opinion on a different health or health care topic each month.

Sign up to our newsletter

Receive the latest news and updates from the Health Foundation

Also in this newsletter

Newsletter feature

Helping the NHS understand what works

26 May 2022
Newsletter feature

Arne Wolters tells us about the IAU’s model of rapid and robust evaluation and their plans to spread...

Blog

Ministers should be wary of declaring war on the NHS

26 May 2022
Blog

Dr Jennifer Dixon argues that history shows that further radical reform is unlikely to fix the...

Blog

Context matters: what’s needed for young people’s mental health?

9 May 2022
Blog

Martina Kane reflects on varied Health Foundation work to better understand and support young...

Chart

How reliant is the NHS in England on international nurse recruitment?

Chart

Registered nurses are the biggest area of workforce shortages in the NHS in England. Compared with...

Newsletter feature

Funding, news and events from May 2022 

26 May 2022
Newsletter feature

The latest funding, news and events from the Health Foundation. 

You might also like...

Event

Health Services Research UK Conference 2022

Event

The Health Foundation is supporting HSR UK’s 15th annual conference on 5–7 July 2022, contributing...

Journal article

Valuing quality in mental healthcare

Journal article

The value of mental healthcare.

Event

Webinar: What does the future look like for the general practice workforce?

Event

In this webinar, we will explore the REAL Centre’s upcoming report on updated NHS workforce supply...

Register
Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101 copy

Get social

A healthy place doesn’t build itself. We all have a part to play in putting the right blocks in place. Visit us a… https://t.co/6PvhUXhm4Q

Follow us on Twitter
Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more