PHE reorganisation is highly risky and justification for the change has not been fully set out Health Foundation response to government’s announcement of plans to establish a new public health agency

18 August 2020

Responding to the government’s announcement of plans to establish a new public health agency, Dr Jennifer Dixon, Chief Executive of the Health Foundation, said:

'The pandemic has significantly challenged the health and care sector in England, in particular its preparedness, resilience and management of emergencies like COVID-19. But reorganising the nation's public health agency in the middle of a pandemic is highly risky, and its justification, or the nature of the change, haven’t been fully set out by the Department of Health and Social Care. Public Health England’s (PHE) effectiveness as an agency has been hampered by a 16% funding cut, and a 22% cut to the wider local public health system since 2015.

'It makes sense to boost PHE’s focus on infection and control and link this more fully to the NHS test and trace programme, and the work of the Joint Biosecurity Centre. But PHE employs 5,500 people, covering a huge range of public health functions across the country – a reorganisation will be a distraction at the worst possible time.

'Setting up and abolishing or merging national agencies like PHE is all too common, and frequently demoralising, wasteful and lacking justification. PHE has been in place for only 7 years, whereas the Robert Koch Institute in Germany (on which the new agency is apparently modelled) for over 125 years. If the government wants a longer-term focus on health protection in an agency, it must examine its own actions in reducing the stability and resilience of national public bodies over the years.

‘PHE’s responsibilities also include addressing slower burn but equally major, public health challenges, such as growing obesity and avoidable inequalities in health. We’ve seen clearly in the pandemic that those in poorest health are themselves at greatest risk of COVID-19. If the country is to be levelled up as the government pledged, the national coordination and oversight of wider public health that PHE currently provides to local authorities will need equal focus and investment. This starts with a proper cross-government strategy to tackle inequalities by focusing on the most deprived areas.'

Media contact

Simon Perry
Simon.Perry@health.org.uk
020 7257 2093

Further reading

Analysis

Creating healthy lives

September 2019
Analysis

This publication makes the case for an ambitious, whole-government approach to long-term investment...

You might also like...

Event

Webinar: Can politicians 'get social care done'?

Event

Understanding the political dynamics behind finally achieving substantive reform of the social care...

Press release

MPs highlight major gaps in the government’s reform agenda for the NHS and social care

Press release

Health Foundation response to the report by the Health and Social Care Select Committee on the...

Chart

NHS Test and Trace performance tracker

Chart

Our analysis on the performance of NHS Test and Trace from 1 October 2020 to 5 May 2021.

Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101 copy

Get social

How can we foster a conducive environment for adopting and sustaining innovation and technology in the NHS? Our la… https://t.co/0FWvrwRFfJ

Follow us on Twitter
Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more