Key points

  • Despite the increasing financial pressure on the NHS over the past decades, there has been little research to understand the distribution and concentration of health care costs across the population.
  • This paper explores for the first time the distribution of both primary and secondary health care costs in England, including GP-prescribed drug cost. Identifying high-cost, high-need patients and examining the way in which they use health care services might help to design initiatives to reduce costs or to improve efficiency.

This working paper was produced as part of a research project to better understand the characteristics and health care utilisation of high-cost, high-need populations across seven countries. See the results of the international study.

The paper adopts a rigorous approach to assigning costs to each patient based on their recorded activity and utilisation. Other researchers may find the methods presented in this paper useful when attempting to cost a full range of health care activity. This working paper has not been peer-reviewed, however we are publishing it as we believe it contributes to the literature in this area.

Summary of findings

  • Analysis identifying the top 5% of users of primary and secondary care services by cost, using a large nationally representative sample in the year 2014/15, found that mean annual costs per patient were over 20 times higher in the top 5% of patients compared with all other patients (£9,789 vs £487).

  • The top 5% of patients accounted for around 50% of the total health care budget for primary care, secondary care and GP-prescribed drug therapy. This meant that more money was spent overall for the top 5% of patients (£147m) than all other patients (£139m).

  • Although high-cost, high-need patients (top 5%) have higher costs across all categories analysed - primary care, outpatient care, emergency care and GP-prescribed drug therapies -, spending on this group was dominated by inpatient care (£6,892 inpatient costs per high-cost, high-need patient).
  • Of the mean cost per patient for inpatient care, 9% and 8% was related to Ambulatory Care Sensitive admissions for the top 5% of patients and all other patients respectively. This suggests that initiatives to improve cost-effectiveness could focus on preventing avoidable inpatient hospital admissions, which is a key tenet of the NHS Long Term Plan.
  • The descriptive analysis indicates that the strongest drivers of being in the high-cost, high-need group are age, multimorbidity and deprivation; however, the paper does not explore the relative contribution of these factors. This suggests the need for a system-wide, long-term response to reducing socio-economic inequalities which may yield benefits to health system efficiency.
  • The design, delivery and management of high-cost, high-need patients have important implications for overall health system costs. Interventions that focus on better managing these patients in primary care and the community, reducing the need for unplanned and costly hospital admissions, could help reduce costs and improve the quality of care.

Cite this publication

Dreyer K, Parry W, Jayatunga W, Deeny S, 'A descriptive analysis of health care use by high cost, high need patients in England'. Health Foundation; 2019.

Further reading

Briefing

Understanding the health care needs of people with multiple health conditions

November 2018

As the number of people with multiple health conditions grows, meeting their needs will be one of...

Press release

Older people living alone are 50% more likely to visit A&E than those who live with others

13 December 2018

Our latest research explores the connection between older people living alone and health care use.

You might also like...

Briefing

The long-term impacts of new care models on hospital use

The briefing examines the impact of Mid-Nottinghamshire's Integrated...

Press release

Government must publish evidence that the contact tracing app works and will not fail those most at risk of COVID-19

The Health Foundation says that there must be greater transparency around the development of the NHS...

News

Ten innovative projects selected to be part of programme to improve analytical capability in health and care services

This programme aims to improve analytical capability in support of health and care services.

Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101 copy

Get social

People living in poorer areas have greater health care needs. Our latest analysis shows that GP practices in areas… https://t.co/ZRYNZY6IWE

Follow us on Twitter
Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more