Key questions addressed

  • What is the role of the Secretary of State for Health?
  • What should it be?
  • How far, in an almost entirely tax-funded NHS, can health ministers be removed from the day-to-day operations of the NHS?
  • How far should they be, if the service is to remain accountable to its patients, to taxpayers and to the public at large?

In Glaziers and Window Breakers, ten former Secretaries of State for Health are asked these questions – and many more. The health secretaries interviewed are:

  • Virginia Bottomley - 'Sometimes you want a window breaker and sometimes you want a glazier.'
  • Kenneth Clarke - 'I closed more hospitals than most people had hot dinners.'
  • William Waldegrave - 'Chequers was surrounded by furious journalists and it was all hopeless.'
  • Stephen Dorrell - 'Of course it doesn’t work if you change it every 5 years.'
  • Frank Dobson - 'I have no problems with command and control.'
  • Alan Milburn - 'Politics is the trap. And the only thing that can break it is politics.'
  • Patricia Hewitt - 'The discovery of the overspend was a really shocking moment.'
  • Alan Johnson - 'Piss off. I’m dealing with this.'
  • Andy Burnham - 'It’s a hard balance. It’s very hard.'
  • Andrew Lansley - 'The more you try to do, the more you get hit for it.'

In addition to their insight, wisdom and advice, the book contains thorough analysis of their words and the landscape in which they had to operate.

Further reading


Lifting the lid on the role of Secretary of State for Health - what really goes on?

Whom did Margaret Thatcher encourage to 'cut the throat' of health reform? And which Secretary of State told the head of Moni...

You might also like...


What does the Liberal Democrats' manifesto mean for health and care?

Hugh Alderwick reflects on the health and care policies set out in the Liberal Democrat manifesto

Press release

Conservatives reportedly commit to ensuring no one will have to sell their home to cover care costs

Health Foundation response to Conservatives’ promise no one will have to sell their home to pay for social care.

Press release

Health Foundation response to the Labour Party manifesto

'Labour’s funding plans provide a welcome recognition of the scale of the challenge facing the NHS'

Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more