Key points

  • The Improvement Analytics Unit (IAU) has evaluated the early impact of two complementary integrated care team initiatives developed in the Fylde Coast NHS vanguard, the Extensive Care Service (ECS) and Enhanced Primary Care (EPC), aimed at adults with complex chronic care needs.  

  • The analysis has found that ECS and EPC patients were admitted to hospital in an emergency respectively 27% and 42% more often compared with their matched control group. Similar trends have been also found across other measures of hospitalisation.   

  • However, due to observable differences remaining between these groups, the study could not conclude that this was a direct causal effect of the new initiatives.   

  • Our analysis suggests that at least in the short term emergency hospital use may increase. As more multidisciplinary teams are established across England, further research is needed to understand why they are not having the anticipated effect on emergency hospital use. 

In this briefing, the Improvement Analytics Unit – a partnership between the Health Foundation and NHS England and NHS Improvement – has found evidence that multidisciplinary teams (MDTs) may increase emergency hospital activity at least in the short term.    

The IAU has evaluated two integrated team initiatives developed in the Fylde Coast NHS vanguard: the Extensive Care Service (ECS) and Enhanced Primary Care (EPC). Both use risk stratification to help identify adults with complex chronic care needs who are at risk of hospitalisation. 

For each initiative, the IAU has carefully selected a matched control group that included individuals with similar characteristics in the local area who had not been referred for the service.  

The analysis has found that neither model of care reduced hospital activity during the period analysed, but it could not conclude that the higher levels of activity were a direct causal effect of ECS or EPC.

This study has limitations. Even after using robust statistical methods, observable differences remained between intervention and matched control groups. Importantly, matched control patients were slightly less ill than the intervention patients.   

The findings are consistent with previous studies and experience of integrated care teams in the UK and in other developed health care settings. Implementation of such services may require a longer time period to reduce population-wide admissions and attendances, as unmet medical need is initially identified and treated among high risk patients by MDT professionals.   

The IAU is currently undertaking new analysis to explore the effectiveness of community MDTs, particularly within specific patient groups and across intervention settings. To find out more, read this statistical analysis protocol

You can also read more detail about the methods used in this report in the accompanying statistical analysis protocol.

Cite this publication

Vestesson E, Shen J, Pariza P, Wolters A. The impact of Extensive Care Service and Enhanced Primary Care in Fylde Coast. 2020. (https://doi.org/10.37829/HF-2020-DA19)

Further reading

Blog

Are multidisciplinary teams an effective tool to reduce emergency hospital activity?

26 November 2020
Blog

New analysis from the Improvement Analytics Unit has found that multidisciplinary teams may increase...

Briefing

The long-term impacts of new care models on hospital use

September 2020
Briefing

The briefing examines the impact of Mid-Nottinghamshire's Integrated...

Briefing

Emergency admissions to hospital from care homes: how often and what for?

July 2019
Briefing

Combined learnings from national linked datasets and focused care home evaluations in Rushcliffe,...

Collection

IAU Resources for robust evaluation

Collection

A collection of resources developed by the Improvement Analytics Unit to promote understanding of...

You might also like...

Blog

Enabling service transformation in practice: reflections on the Wade-Gery review

Blog

Will the Wade-Gery review enable the NHS to make a leap forwards on tech and data? Tim Horton...

Press release

Social care COVID-19 deaths highlight need for government to go further on funding and reform

Press release

Health Foundation response to Office for National Statistics data on deaths in the care sector in...

Consultation response

Briefing on the Health and Care Bill: House of Lords Second Reading

Consultation response

Our briefing for the House of Lords on the Health and Care Bill 2021/22.

Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101 copy

Get social

This week's @ONS data revealed that nearly 25,000 people in care homes died of COVID-19 in 2020 – around one in six… https://t.co/5hpE0IvWUH

Follow us on Twitter
Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more