Using safety cases in industry and healthcare

A pragmatic review of the use of safety cases in safety critical industries – lessons and prerequisites for their application in healthcare

December 2012

Thumbnail

Key points

  • The report highlights a number of potential benefits of using safety cases in healthcare, including:
    • promoting structured thinking about risk among clinicians and fostering multidisciplinary communication about safety
    • integrating evidence sources
    • aiding communication among stakeholders
    • making the implicit explicit.
  • Risks and challenges identified include safety cases:
    • becoming a paper exercise
    • being removed from everyday practice
    • being produced by the wrong people.

This report presents the results of a study that reviewed the use of safety cases in six safety-critical industries, as well as the emerging use of safety cases in healthcare.

The aims of the study were to describe safety case use in other industries, to make pragmatic recommendations for the adoption of safety cases in healthcare and to outline possible healthcare application scenarios.

The core of a safety case is typically a risk-based argument and corresponding evidence to demonstrate that:

  • all risks associated with a particular system have been identified
  • appropriate risk controls have been put in place
  • there are appropriate processes in place to monitor the effectiveness of the risk controls and the safety performance of the system on an ongoing basis.

The purpose of a safety case is to provide a structured argument, supported by a body of evidence, that provides a compelling, comprehensible and valid case that a system is acceptably safe for a given application in a given context

The use of safety cases is an accepted best practice in UK safety-critical industries and is adopted by companies as a means of providing rigour and structure to their safety management systems.

    The Health Foundation is exploring the development of safety cases in healthcare through our Safer Clinical Systems programme. The learning from this work could have far-reaching implications, not just for how staff assure safety within their clinical settings, but also for how the regulators and commissioners of healthcare services monitor patient safety in the UK.

    You might also like...

    Press release

    A deeply concerning picture of the state of screening programmes in England

    The Health Foundation responds to the National Audit Office’s investigation into the management of health screening.

    Improvement project

    Empowering prescribers to empower patients and fellow professionals: a novel approach to safe, person-centred practice

    This project is aiming to improve the experiences of inpatients on insulin and the education of foundation trainees.

    Improvement project

    Professional wellbeing: Effective management of staff fatigue during the night shift

    This project will involve co-designing a fatigue risk management strategy to help teams effectively manage night shift fatigu...

    Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

    Work with us

    We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

    View current vacancies
    Artboard 101 copy 2

    The Q Community

    Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

    Find out more