Competition policy in five European countries What can be learned for health policy in England?

July 2017

Luigi Siciliani
Martin Chalkley
Hugh Gravelle
Thumbnail

Key points

  • Proximity to the health care provider, rather than quality, remains the key driver of patient choice.
  • There is potential tension between stimulating quality competition and controlling expenditure because restrictions on hospital treatments imply that money does not follow the patient, and hospitals may react by making access more difficult or letting their waiting times increase.
  • Information for assessing proposed hospital mergers requires improvement, particularly information on quality.
  • There is limited scope for further expansion in the use of private providers to treat NHS patients given the current focus on controlling expenditure.
  • The economic rationale for controlling entry of providers into general practice is unclear.
  • Selective contracting for patients with chronic and multiple conditions to reduce fragmentation of care raises concerns for competition and regulation. This is because of the long-term nature of the implied contracts and the restricted pool of potential providers willing to bid for these contracts.

To understand how competition could be used more effectively in primary and secondary care services in England, this working paper explores how policies affecting competition have been implemented and promoted in health systems in five countries: France, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway and Portugal.

In conventional markets, customers are attracted to particular suppliers by a more appealing combination of price and quality. But in health care, patients are usually insulated from costs and may find it difficult to judge quality due to information asymmetries and their infrequent use of services.

This means that the question – what do we expect or want of competition? – is not so easily answered in health care settings, and lessons from other sectors might not apply.

Further reading

Blog

NHS competition policy and the EU

06 July 2017

Nearly two years ago, the Health Foundation commissioned a team of researchers at the University of...

Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more