Unfortunately, your browser is too old to work on this website. Please upgrade your browser
Skip to main content
Blog

A healthier workplace needs more than good intentions – it needs good evidence

Published 17 April 2025
Time to read clock icon About 5 mins
Authors
  • Nida Broughton

Nida Broughton, Interim Managing Director, BIT UK, and Commissioner, Commission for Healthier Working Lives, discusses the importance of evidence on what works for employers to provide healthier workplaces.

Employers spend billions of pounds every year supporting the health of their employees. This includes providing occupational health services (£1.6bn a year alone), health insurance and assistance programmes as well as putting time and effort into strategies to improve workplace culture and line management practices – important for both mental health and productivity. 

This is a good thing. In the UK, every year over 300,000 people leave their jobs and end up out of the workforce with work-limiting health conditions. Employers are crucial to stemming this flow, and many are already taking action to keep people in work. 

But do we really know what works in terms of practical steps employers can take towards building a healthier workforce? Are we even asking the question? This matters, because if we don’t know the answer, and we’re not investing in finding out, efforts from employers risk having little impact. 

Diversity training provides a cautionary tale. Many employers have invested heavily in tackling a lack of diversity in hiring and progression. Unconscious bias training, based on the idea that awareness of one’s biases can help overcome them, has become especially popular. Yet, when the outcomes of such trainings are measured, in many cases they fail to show an impact. Even worse, some studies show that they can backfire.  

We need to make sure actions towards health at work have a real impact. The Commission for Healthier Working Lives, of which I was a part, heard that employers lack ‘real-world examples and evidence on business outcomes to guide effective action’. It doesn’t help that what works in one sector doesn’t always work in another. To take an obvious example, offering employees the ability to work remotely is much easier for office-based jobs than for those working in social care. Flexible working can also be difficult in, say, front-line transport roles, where long shifts and operational constraints are common. And there are already signs the diversity training story is repeating itself for workplace health, with employers investing in resilience training, mindfulness and wellbeing apps that are leaving staff no better off. 

This isn’t the first time the government has faced a situation where there’s a need for action, but a lack of evidence on what to do. What Works centres, set up to bring together existing evidence and fund studies where there are gaps in the evidence base, are designed to tackle exactly this. For example, the Education Endowment Fund has been transformational in the education space, funding over 100 trials since it was set up in 2011 – including evaluating breakfast clubs, tutoring programmes and early language support. Their work has helped the public sector avoid waste and invest in what really works. 

The Commission’s report recommends the government commit funding to build and share evidence on what works, ensuring best practice is rigorously tested, practical for different business settings and adaptable to a changing world of work. There are different ways to do this – from having a single What Works centre to developing a network based on existing trade and industry bodies. There may also be a case for focusing on supporting specific sectors to build their capability to generate and apply evidence. 

Whatever the model used to gather evidence and share evidence, the following principles can help ensure its success: 

  • Give businesses the practical evidence they need. A successful model will need to cultivate deep partnerships with employers and sector bodies – understanding what matters to them and working with them to jointly discover and test new ideas. A good start would be to scout what businesses are doing now and evaluate the most common approaches. Are they working as well as businesses think they are? This is not a call for more research funding for research’s sake.
  • Plug into existing data. Existing data from employers, insurers and the government can provide clues about promising interventions to test further – for example, seeing which businesses have particularly low sickness rates and running studies to figure out why.
  • Have a plan for scaling what works. It’s never enough to find out what works. There must be a plan to spread best practice across employers. This should be factored in right at the start, because it will impact what should be tested (prioritising ideas that can scale fast) and how (it’s important to figure out not just whether things work but why – that will tell you the key elements to retain as the idea is scaled and adapted to other businesses and sectors). Broadly, there are two ways of scaling best practice:
    • Disseminate and hope: Many employers are actively looking for practical, evidence-based solutions. We need to work closely with these employers from the start, docking into existing industry bodies. It’s also important that when we test ideas, we measure business performance as well as health outcomes to help build the case for adopting best practice. Our Commission report proposes scaling up a caseworker-led service to support employers and employees. This could serve as another “node” in the system, helping to identify, test and disseminate practices that work.
    • Policy and regulation: We need to be realistic that the ‘disseminate and hope’ option won’t always get us to where we need to be. Improving health and business performance often go together, but not always. That means we also need to test ideas with an eye to building the case for government intervention, whether that’s new regulation, increasing funding or shaping markets to sharpen competition between employers on working conditions, including through procurement policy.

Well-funded What Works centres typically cost £5m to £10m a year, much of which goes towards working with employers to test and disseminate what works. That may seem like a lot, but it’s tiny compared with the cost of poor employee health: sickness absence and attrition alone are estimated to cost employers £40bn a year. 

We can only achieve the goal of a healthier workforce if we understand practically how to make it happen. 

Further reading

You might also like...