Unfortunately, your browser is too old to work on this website. Please upgrade your browser
Skip to main content
Blog

The three big ideas in the Milburn review that link health to the NEET crisis

Published 20 November 2026
Time to read clock icon About 5 mins
Authors

One of the most striking things about Alan Milburn's review of young people and work is its sheer scope. Across nearly 300 pages, there is scarcely an area of domestic public policy it does not touch, spanning employment, education, health, welfare, skills and local government. 

What comes through strongly is why health matters so much to the issue of young people, work and education.

Firstly, prolonged periods not in education, employment or training (NEET) are associated with a range of poorer outcomes later in life. Young people who spend longer disconnected from work and education are more likely to experience poverty, lower earnings and less secure employment throughout adulthood, which are in turn associated with poorer health. Tackling the NEET crisis should therefore be thought of as a preventative health intervention.

Secondly, ill health appears to be playing an increasingly important role in driving young people away from work and education in the first place. Our analysis shows that nearly half (44%) of young people who were NEET in 2025 reported a work-limiting health condition, up from 26% in 2015. That represents a relative increase of 70% over the past decade, driven by big increases in the numbers of young people reporting mental health and neurodevelopmental conditions. 

As health is now both a consequence and cause of youth economic inactivity, any serious strategy to increase participation among young people must therefore take tackling health barriers just as seriously as education and skills support. 

What does Milburn’s review say?

Three big ideas relating to young people’s health immediately stand out in Milburn’s review.

The first is the creation of a new Youth Opportunities Service. In practice, this proposal has two elements: the development of a national caseworker-based system for young people who are NEET, or at risk of becoming so; and bringing together a fragmented landscape of support into a more coherent and accessible offer.

This is an enormously ambitious proposal. If implemented well, it could be genuinely transformative, as we argued in our briefing ahead of the review.

Too often, young people and their families face a confusing patchwork of programmes, providers and eligibility criteria. The Youth Opportunities Service seeks to address this by creating a single front door into support and ensuring young people are connected to the help that is right for them, backed by a legal guarantee.

The proposal matters for health because it has the potential to intervene early, before relatively manageable challenges become long-term barriers to participation.

Under the model set out in the review, a young person experiencing the first signs of a health problem or facing circumstances that put them at risk of falling out of work or education would have someone they can turn to. Their needs could be identified quickly, and they could be connected to the right support, whether that is preventative mental health support or assistance with practical barriers such as caring responsibilities.

But the value of the approach is not only in the services it unlocks. The relationship itself may be beneficial. Having someone who understands your circumstances and helps you to make progress can provide a sense of direction at a time when many young people feel stuck. This would be a major departure from the brief and transactional support that young people have described accessing through Job Centres.

A second big idea in the review is the argument that the health system itself should take greater responsibility for participation outcomes.

One element of this is the review's critique of fit notes, which it argues are too often a missed opportunity for intervention. For many young people, a fit note becomes an end point rather than the start of a conversation about what support they need to overcome barriers to participation.

Linking fit notes more closely to the proposed Youth Opportunities Service could help change this. Rather than simply recording somebody's inability to work, fit notes could and should become a gateway to practical support. 

More fundamentally, the review argues that the NHS should be held more accountable for youth participation outcomes. In particular, it proposes a greater role for integrated care boards in supporting young people with health conditions to remain connected to education and employment.

This would represent a significant shift from the current system. Participation outcomes have rarely been treated as a core measure of success for health services.

Turning that ambition into reality will not be straightforward. It will require aligned funding, clear accountability and strong local partnerships between health services, local authorities, mayoral strategic authorities and employment support providers. We recently published a report with RAND Europe that highlighted how challenging this can be, especially when expertise and money is locked into providing other services. But it is one of the Milburn review's potentially most far-reaching recommendations.

The final big idea covered by the review relates to the welfare system.

The review proposes a significant rethink of how financial support is provided to young people with health conditions. With the Timms Review of disability benefits expected next week, we will set out more detailed reflections on the impact of these proposals shortly. However, much will depend on the detailed design of any replacement for the current system of health-related benefits, and the impact on young people's incomes will ultimately be determined by those details.

Invest in services to support youth participation

From a health perspective, however, there is a key question around sequencing.

A central argument running through the Milburn review is that too many young people face barriers to participation that the current system is poorly equipped to address.

That raises an important challenge for government. If welfare reform moves ahead before the infrastructure needed to support participation is in place, there is a risk of increasing hardship, deepening disengagement and pushing people further from work. Elsewhere, we have argued for a benefits system that brings financial support and practical health support together, recognising that adequate incomes enable people to engage with the help that can move them closer to work.

The main lesson is that success of any new welfare settlement will depend not only on the design of benefits themselves, but on whether government first invests in the services, support and local partnerships that help young people participate. 

The most important message from the review is that youth participation should not be treated solely as an employment challenge. Health has become both a cause and a consequence of youth economic inactivity. The task now is to ensure that government builds the support infrastructure that enables participation before expecting welfare reform to deliver it.

Further reading

You might also like...