What does the general election mean for health and inequalities in Scotland?
With just over a week to go until polling day, health has only begun to take centre stage in general election debates north and south of the border. Yet even as it does so, the focus is primarily on NHS spend and waiting times.
These issues matter, of course, but the debate headlines mask a stark truth. Across the UK, health inequalities between rich and poor persist. But as highlighted by an election briefing from the Fraser of Allander Institute and the Centre for Health Policy, inequalities are even more apparent in Scotland.
While many policies that affect health outcomes, notably health care itself, are devolved, responsibility for some of the key areas of policy that affect living standards and health outcomes are shared between the Scottish and the UK governments. And even where policies are devolved, there may still be an indirect impact if there is a change in UK government spending.
The scale of the challenge in Scotland was spelt out in the Health Foundation’s 2023 report on health and health inequalities, Leave no one behind. The report, which examined how Scotland had fared since devolution, highlighted stalling improvements in the decade before the pandemic and, in many cases, widening inequalities.
By 2019 the gap in healthy life expectancy between people living in the most and least socioeconomically deprived 10% of local areas in Scotland had widened to 24 years. And in the same year people living in the poorest two-fifths of households were almost eight times as likely to report poor health as the richest fifth.
Yet as the briefing points out, in Scotland (as across the UK), people express consistently high levels of concern about health. Recent findings from Understanding Scotland found that 52% of Scots considered the NHS and health care to be one of the top three issues facing the country.
But Scottish voters’ concerns about health and its determinants don’t stop there. Understanding Scotland found that 40% of Scots put the cost of living in their top three issues. Poverty and inequality featured in the top three issues for 20% of respondents, housing for 17%, and education and schools for 15%. However, trust in politicians is low, especially within communities with the poorest health.
We also know that the relationship between poor health and living standards has become more acute as the cost-of-living crisis has exacerbated the already fragile state of many families' finances. Understanding Scotland revealed more than half of Scots reported worse financial health compared with the previous year, with significant impacts on mental and physical health.
The briefing also takes a closer look at the recent trends affecting two groups of particular concern identified in Leave no one behind, young children and young adult men. While large gaps exist between the most and least deprived areas in Scotland for a range of health outcomes in early childhood, rates of drug deaths, long higher in Scotland, have recently soared above the rates in the rest of the UK.
In its first election briefing, the Health Foundation set out the case for a prevention-led approach to tackling the UK’s fraying health, the burden it places on public services and the limitations on our future prosperity. The briefing identified five barriers to a prevention-led policy agenda across the UK: short-termism, siloed government working, the current financial climate, depleted local government resourcing and the failure of government to galvanise all parts of society.
All these barriers feature in Leave no one behind, while the issue of siloed government working was also highlighted in the Scottish Parliament’s Health, Social Care and Sport Committee health inequalities inquiry in 2022.
It is clear Scotland does have the power to act and build on strong policy intent to reduce stubbornly high health inequalities. However, the fiscal context ahead poses significant challenges. Greater collaboration between the Scottish and UK governments is critical.
Even as the focus of the election campaign in Scotland has shifted onto health, the wider determinants driving inequalities – including falling living standards and rising poverty – have not had the attention they deserve. As polling day approaches, it is vital that the election discourse shifts to these issues.
Whatever the outcome of the election and the balance of powers and resources between the Westminster and Holyrood parliaments, urgent action is required. And pledges made in a UK election context will have an important role to play in determining whether health inequalities in Scotland are reversed in the next few years.
Chris Creegan (@Chris_Creegan) is Programme Director and Chair of the steering group for a 3-year Health Foundation funded programme to drive improving health and reducing inequalities in Scotland.