Unfortunately, your browser is too old to work on this website. Please upgrade your browser
Skip to main content
Blog

Getting better with age? What’s behind changes in health between the 2011 and 2021 censuses

Published 13 December 2024
Time to read clock icon About 4 mins
Authors

With the government focused on showing more immediate progress against its health mission, recent Office for National Statistics releases shed light on the scale of the long-term challenge of improving health and reducing inequalities in the UK – but also in measuring progress.

The headline measure of healthy life expectancy – an estimate of the average years people live in good health combining life expectancy and self-reported health – showed little improvement in the decade before the pandemic, and is yet to return to pre-pandemic levels. Inequalities also remain wide, with the latest data showing an 18-year gap in healthy life expectancy between local areas – almost a fifth wider than in 2011 to 2013. This sets a challenging context for the government’s target to improve health and reduce inequalities between regions. 

Healthy life expectancy at birth being lower in 2021 to 2023 than pre-pandemic is at least in part due to higher COVID-19 mortality bearing down on the life expectancy part of the metric. The lack of improvement in the health component may not seem surprising given the UK’s ageing population. As older people tend to experience more health issues than younger people, you could reasonably expect an older population would be less likely to report being in good health than a younger one. However, looking beyond the headline metric of healthy life expectancy at birth and a recent related Office for National Statistics analysis tells a different story.

Surprising findings

Using the last two censuses, the analysis shows the proportion of people with self-reported good health in 2021 was 1.0% percentage point higher than in 2011 in England, and 1.3% percentage points higher in Wales. While not large, this increase occurred against the headwind of an ageing population – a greater share of older people in the population over the same decade would have meant a decline in health prevalence of 1.2% in England and 1.7% in Wales. Given this improvement in reported good health, what accounts for the lack of improvement in healthy life expectancy?

Despite the significant improvement in the health of people aged 70 years and older (of between 8 and 10 percentage points) there has also been a small but concerning decline for people aged 40 years and younger (of up to 1 percentage point). 

What lies behind this pattern?

In very broad terms, worse health outcomes for younger members of the population is a pattern we may have expected over the decade 2011 to 2021. It reflects patterns in healthy life expectancy previously unpicked by OHID that highlight a downward effect in self-reported good health at younger ages. However, the relative scale of improvement among the older population is surprising.

It is also important to note the timing of the second national census and its potential influence on the findings. Amid the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, one might have expected self-reported health to have declined both through the direct impact of the virus itself and disruptions to health care services. So why did self-reported health appear to improve? There are several possible explanations, with researchers in Amsterdam who observed increases in self-reported health suggesting that people not infected by the virus may have assessed their health more positively when comparing themselves with those unwell with COVID-19.

Why does it matter?

The measure of self-reported health – typically asked simply as ‘how is your health in general?’ – is common in large, population-based surveys worldwide. It has been validated against many physician-reported measures of health and has been shown to predict morbidity and mortality. It is therefore a highly impactful tool for understanding the health of the population. It can inform health-related policy and planning, with applications from predicting future health service use and costs to financial preparation for sick-leave-related salary support. It is also, more broadly and perhaps more importantly, an indicator of our ability to participate fully in society and lead fulfilling lives.

Closing the gap in healthy life expectancy between regions was an election manifesto pledge, and this latest healthy life expectancy data release – partly based on the census – may serve as a baseline measure. The other source used to track health progress between censuses, the Annual Population Survey, is suffering from a low response rate. This has led to a lack of confidence in estimates of UK employment levels and highlights a risk of uncertainty in estimating self-reported health too. 

Shifting existing trends in healthy life expectancy is likely to be a significant challenge, but that challenge will be harder still if there is uncertainty about where we are starting from and being able to track the progress made. To better understand these changes in health, we are supporting further investigation into these findings. The Office for National Statistics will be delving further into the data in the first half of 2025 with a more detailed analysis of changes in people’s health across the two census timepoints.

Further reading

You might also like...