Strengthening clinical leadership and management
Lessons from our research in the UK and US
Key points
- Strengthening clinical leadership and management is an important means of helping the NHS to improve quality outcomes and boost operational productivity and efficiency. Evidence suggests clinical leadership and management are associated with high organisational performance and can bring a variety of benefits for leadership and organisational decision making.
- Policymakers and politicians from all parties see clinical leadership and management as crucial in making more efficient and productive use of service and workforce capacity, without compromising clinical quality or outcomes.
- Our research detected signs that progress is being made in supporting greater clinical leadership and management within the NHS, with more clinicians now likely to consider this as a career path. But challenges remain in improving access to management opportunities across clinical professions and improving the training and development on offer to aspiring clinician leaders and managers.
- Lessons can be learned from the highest performing US medical centres in promoting clinical leadership and management – even without the same level of resources available in the NHS. These include more visible backing for management, parity of esteem for managers from different backgrounds, improved processes for recruitment and talent management, and a better training and development offer.
- Increasing clinical leadership and management shouldn’t be seen in isolation as a panacea for performance challenges. Clinical leaders and managers cannot necessarily trump the culture and constraints they work within. Further, given clinician leaders’ commitment to collaborative leadership and coalition building, it is likely that they will be most successful in open, learning-focused organisational cultures.
- Greater clinical leadership and management needs to be one component of a multifaceted improvement strategy. Policymakers and providers must ensure that strategies to strengthen clinical leadership and management are integrated with the drive to create organisation and system-wide approaches to improvement, following the recently launched NHS Impact approach.
Management involves the control, monitoring or organisation of people, processes and systems in order to achieve specific goals. It has been described as consisting of six key tasks: planning, allocating resources, coordinating the work of others, motivating staff, monitoring output and taking responsibility for the process.
Leadership refers to influencing and inspiring others in pursuit of common goals, setting the tone and direction for a group or organisation, and identifying and framing problems for others to solve. In practice, leadership and management are closely interconnected and health care employees at all levels often have to deploy both leadership and management skills in order to carry out their job effectively.
All clinical and care professions are involved to some extent in the leadership and management of organisations, services, systems and professional groups. However, this long read is primarily focused on leadership and management roles undertaken by clinicians working in large provider organisations like NHS trusts, such as doctors, nurses and allied health professionals. These roles include both those specifically reserved for clinicians, such as medical director, matron and clinical lead positions, and roles open to all staff, such as chief executive, chief operating officer or divisional director, that happen to be held by people who are or used to be practising clinicians.