Burnham’s devolution focus could deliver a genuine step change in how we improve health
In his first weeks in office, the new prime minister has made a series of pledges with the potential to lead to a very different state: one that is preventative, focused on improving local outcomes and can, ultimately, better support healthier lives.
A genuine step change could come in the promise of further devolution and the opportunity to shift to a different way of delivering policy, supporting the prime minister’s ambition to make lives better in every postcode.
A different approach has become increasingly necessary, as a greater share of resources are being absorbed by acute need rather than prevention. This partly reflects a historic lack of investment in public service provision, with consequences felt both in the quality of people’s lives and in pressures on government spending.
The agenda being set out by the new prime minister provides reason for optimism.
As our recent analysis shows, there is serious untapped economic potential in the UK's health. Reversing the decline in the UK’s working-age health back to that of 2014 could provide a £57bn boost to the economy and a £72bn improvement in government finances. Policies designed to improve people’s living standards and boost growth can also aid their health and deliver additional economic benefits in return.
High levels of economic inactivity due to ill health and a rising number of young people out of education or employment are big challenges the prime minister has acknowledged. Early signals to improve vocational pathways and support young people into work are encouraging, as the consequences of failing to protect the health of our working-age population, and those younger, are all too apparent.
A genuine focus on local health needs
The building blocks of health – such as employment opportunities, transport infrastructure, housing conditions, and education and skills – can vary significantly between places. So, an understanding of the needs of local populations is vital to support local growth and health improvement. Through our Mayoral Regions Programme, we have seen strategic authorities take action to integrate health into transport, skills, employment and local growth planning. These examples suggest the opportunity is real but also that devolution will only improve health if strategic authorities have the capacity, evidence and partnerships with integrated care boards, service providers, voluntary organisations and communities.
Actions and announcements to date around devolution are significant and ambitious. Rather than further piecemeal handing over of powers, a greater vision is being articulated. Done properly, devolution has the potential to make a real difference and break down barriers to a more preventative state.
No. 10 North can provide the political leadership to drive change. It also has the potential to rewire government operations, including making sure there is accountability for delivery across and between different levels of government.
Mooted powers on tax revenues and grants can help move beyond existing funding models – often short term and overly centralised – that can constrain policy progress. But it will be important to make sure that new inequalities aren’t created by weaker economies, which may be less able to raise revenues, being left behind.
An example of the key role devolution can play to address knotty policy challenges is in tackling the growing number of young people neither earning nor learning. This requires providing the structures to link together local support for employment, health and skills, and rationalising various existing health and employment-related pilots and programmes. But it also shows the importance of coherence with the centre. Young people need a social security system that supports them to transition into work – and provides an adequate income while doing so to protect their health.
This can’t all happen overnight; the right mechanisms will need to be developed and put into place to enable this ‘rewiring’. That includes a focus on evaluation and monitoring, which will be essential to show whether devolved powers are translating into better outcomes for local populations. Lessons can be drawn from Greater Manchester, but the government can also look wider for examples of best practice. CIPFA’s prevention spend framework provides an example of the types of mechanisms needed so that places can understand how best to spend their money and track progress.
Balancing short-term wins with long-term goals
Politically, time to get big reform right is often in short supply. People will need to feel a tangible difference is being made to their lives before the next election – up to 3 years isn’t very long to enact meaningful change. And global instability means economic growth can so easily be knocked off course.
The challenge is to secure short-term wins without losing sight of longer term goals and to maximise the benefits of policy change, which can often fall across different parts of government.
Despite a key manifesto pledge, there has been little progress on Labour’s health mission. A new prime minister and a new health secretary offer an opportunity to reboot the mission approach, joining up the cross-government action needed to make sustained progress on complicated and structural issues like improving the nation’s health.
While making these shifts won’t be easy, it has been welcome to see the prime minister’s willingness to rethink how the state works to enable places to deliver for the health of their local populations. If good growth is to be a reality in every postcode, then a focus on improving health from the start will be key to lasting success.